Al Hawadeth for Arab Americans

اليوم :
  • :
  • :

Pro-Israel Groups Trying, but Can’t Stop Change.

Publish Date: 5/12/2022 6:44:33 AM


Dr. James J. Zogby © Washington Watch

May 6, 2022


Arab American Institute


Because there has been a noticeable shift in American attitudes toward the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, pro-Israel groups in the US are flailing about in wild desperation. Examples abound:

Working in concert with the government of Israel, they have pushed more than 30 states to criminalize support for efforts to boycott, divest, or sanction Israel.

Paralleling this is their campaign to pass legislation on the national and state levels that will expand the definition of anti-Semitism to include many forms of legitimate criticism of Israel. This expanded definition is not only to be used in the prosecution of some hate crimes, it is also making its way onto college campuses and local school boards and being used to stifle student protests against Israeli policies and to influence what can and can’t be taught and who can and can’t teach about the Middle East and its history.

And concerned with the increased number of congressional candidates who are openly critical of Israeli policies, new pro-Israel political action committees have been created to support candidates who will not question Israeli behavior or to oppose those who have taken issue with Israel’s treatment of Palestinians. In just the first quarter of this year, these PACs have already raised and spent millions largely to smear the reputations of those they seek to defeat.

Combined, these efforts are both undemocratic and dangerous. They are designed to intimidate and/or punish those who dare to criticize Israeli policies and, therefore, to silence needed debate about US policy in the Middle East.


Much of what these pro-Israel groups are doing is merely an extension of tactics they have employed for decades. Pro-Israel PACs have been bundling campaign contributions for decades and using them to reward candidates who endorsed unquestioning support for Israel and punish those who showed even the slightest inclination to challenge that state’s policies. And major pro-Israel groups have also, for decades, used their good offices to smear critics of Israel with the charge of being anti-Semitic or terrorist sympathizers—a sure way to end debate and harm the reputation of those advocating for Palestinian human rights.

The political environment they created with these tactics was both distorted and dangerous. They may have won votes in Congress, but in many cases members of Congress cast their votes more out of fear of the political fallout rather than their own policy positions, including ones they knew would better serve U.S. interests. I used to keep a list of congresspeople who had told to me: “I’m really with you, but you know how AIPAC is. I have to be careful not to anger them.”

The impact of being smeared as an anti-Semite or a supporter of terror was even more damaging. Some Arab Americans and others who spoke out in support of Palestinians lost jobs and speaking engagements. Arab American groups were excluded from political coalitions. Some Arab Americans were denied the right to participate in the political process, limiting our ability to represent and defend our community. More ominously, others endured death threats and even acts of hate violence.

But despite their best efforts to pummel opponents into silence and submission, criticism of Israeli policies has only grown. Polls show that a majority of all Americans want to condition US aid to Israel based on their violations of Palestinian human rights. A plurality of Americans see support for sanctioning or boycotting Israel as legitimate. And support for Palestinians and criticism of Israel have dramatically increased among Democrats.

In addition to empowered Arab Americans, Black Americans and young voters have become more outspoken. Of great importance in this regard, young American Jews have become organized and emboldened to challenge the pro-Israel bent of the establishment organizations that have for too long dominated the politics of their community. As a result, while in the past, one could count just one or two congressional campaigns where Palestinian rights were an issue, this year there are dozens.

All this combined has created panic in the hardline pro-Israel community. Like the little Dutch boy in the famous story, they are trying to put their fingers in the dike to hold back the flood, but with so many leaks, they find themselves at a loss. Hence the desperate measures.

This panic was evident in a bizarre speech given last week by the head of the Anti-Defamation League (ADL). After citing an increase in anti-Semitic incidents, he sought to pin the blame on critics of Israel, singling out a pro-Palestinian student group, a movement of progressive young Jews, and a Muslim group. He came to the bizarre conclusion that anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism. He then proposed accelerating the measures designed to silence debate about and punish legitimate criticism of Israel.

There are so many additional comments one could make about this hysterical effort at misdirection, but it suffices to say that it is dangerous. Pro-Israel groups may win a few races because they’ve smeared an honest candidate. They may damage a few careers and cause threats to a few courageous academics or advocates for justice. They may also pass a few unconstitutional laws banning free speech. But, at the end of the day, they will not succeed in silencing the growing criticism of Israel because what is spurring it on isn’t anti-Semitism, it’s the brutal and aggressive hardline apartheid policies of that state. The net result of their heavy-handed tactics will only breed anger and resentment, and even more importantly, deeper partnerships and more organizing in support of justice. The opinions expressed in our published works are those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinions of الحوادث Al Hawadeth Newspaper, Al Hawadeth for Arab Americans, or their Editors.

Read Too


By Professor Bob Rabboh* Today, the U.S -Qatari relationships has never been stronger. Frequent visits to Doha in recent months by U. S officials including Senators and U.S Representatives. Significantly, Qatar officially becomes U.S partner in the Gulf, and a major non-NATO all alleys. A move that regards the partnership between Doha and Washington, a status that paves the way for greate...

Palestinians Can Learn from Irish Successes نموذج التحرر الأيرلندي

By Dr. James J. Zogby © President of Arab American Institute النسخة العربية من المقال تتبع في الاسفل Last week, Mary Lou McDonald, the President of Sinn Fein, the Irish republican/socialist party, and leader of the opposition in the Irish Parliament, addressed a European Union conference. When asked how she would direct Irish foreign policy, her remarks were both compelling and ins...


By Bob A. Rabboh, Ph.D The death of Shireen Abu Akleh has become a central issue for the Palestinian cause. Her killing highlights the main issues of the conflict and continued suffering of the Palestinians. On May 11th, the iconic journalist was shot and killed by an Israeli soldier while reporting on Israeli military raid of refugee camp in Jenin. Thus, there is no shortage of evidence...

Shireen Abu Aqla was an active, brilliant and courageous reporter

Isa Qasim In Palestine the struggle never stopped. Since early last century, the life of a number of Palestinian leaders and activists ended, one way or another. But has the Palestinian cause waned, or has the aspirations faded? No way. Similarly, over the years, has the aggressors' appetite for aggression, deceit, chicanery, or plans to steal or swallow the Palestinian land or property ended or...

Pro-Israel Groups Trying, but Can’t Stop Change.

Dr. James J. Zogby © Washington Watch May 6, 2022 President Arab American Institute Because there has been a noticeable shift in American attitudes toward the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, pro-Israel groups in the US are flailing about in wild desperation. Examples abound: Working in concert with the government of Israel, they have pushed more than 30 states to criminalize suppor...

Who outsmarts whom, Nature or man?

Isa Qasim The weather today is reasonable, on the cool side but dry and no storms and the sun is bright and courteous. But for how long would this last? Why do I say that? Because Nature's behavior has, in recent months, been far from normal or accommodating. I do not recall that in my lifetime, and my lifetime has been long, that we went through a similar attitude by nature. Very heavy ra...

حقوق فلسطينية منتهكة

English version follows أثناء قراءتي لتقرير منظمة «هيومن رايتش واتش» الجديد الذي يرصد الانتهاكات التي يتعرض لها الفلسطينيون، انتباتني مجموعة من المشاعر. التقرير ترك لديّ أيضاً سؤالاً كبيراً. لقد تأثرت بعمق بالطابع العلمي الصارم للتقرير. وفي الوقت نفسه استدعى التقرير مشاعر الغضب والحزن العميق. التقرير يمثل دراسة كاملة بشكل استثنائي ترصد بالتفصيل ليس فقط الوسائل الكثيرة، التي تم من خلا...

الهدية.. فيلم مبدع عن واقع فلسطيني معقدThe Present

ENGLISH VERSION FOLLOWS جيمس زغبي إننا جميعاً مدينون لفرح نابلسي بدين كبير من العرفان. ففي فيلم يمتد 24 دقيقة فقط بعنوان «الهدية»، تعري نابلسي الغلظة التي يتعرض لها الفلسطينيون من خلال سرد قصة مؤثرة للغاية عن أسرة فلسطينية. والشيق بشكل خاص في الأمر أنه بعد فوز الفيلم بجوائز في عدد من المهرجانات السينمائية الدولية، تم ترشيحه لجائزة الأوسكار لأفضل فيلم روائي قصير. وقصة الفيلم بسيطة لك...

تيه المثقفين

" لم نعد نفّصل الحروف على قياس الحدث،كما كان يفعل كتّاب سبعينيات وثمانينيات القرن الماضي،وكأن الكتابة كانت مبارزة بين ضدّين،وتحتاج إلى لأمة الفارس ودروعه،وزرده وسيوفه! كانت الكتابة تحدّياً وإثبات موقف،لأن المواجهة حامية،ودائرة المواجهة ضيقة،ولكن دوائر تأثيرها تتسع،لتشمل العالم كُلّه،أو هكذا كان يُخيّل للكاتب. الآن وفي ظلّ نقلة الوعي التي أحدثتها ثورة الإتصالات،أدركنا أننا لسنا لاعبين رئيسيين،و...

معنى الحزن في الحياة

إبراهيم أبو عواد / كاتب من الأردن هل نعشق الحزن أو نَكرهه ؟. كُلُّنا نهرب من الإجابة كما نهرب من الماضي . الماضي لا ينام ولا يموت . الماضي هو الحاضرُ والمستقبلُ . هل الحزن شعور أو موقف فلسفي ؟. ينبغي أن نُحدِّد المفاهيم قبل أن نطرحها للنقاش . الحزن غابةٌ بِكر غير مُكْتَشَفَة ، وعلينا اكتشافها. رُبَّما نُنقِّب عن الحزن لنعرف معنى الفرح . يُعلِّمنا الحزن أن نُغيِّر زاوية الرؤية باس...

The Adventure of the Peculiar Protocols, book review

Review by Brenda Repland When an agent of the British Secret Service is found floating in the Thames, the motive seems to be related to the manuscript she was carrying. The document purports to be the minutes of a meeting of a secret group intent on . . . taking over the world. Could it be real? Sherlock’s brother, Mycroft, enlists the investigative help of his brother and Dr. Wats...

A Passion For Justice

Published on Washington Watch July 17, 2020 By Dr. James J. Zogby Washington’s elites, like Hollywood’s, can be quite shallow, placing value on titles, wealth, or appearance. Back in the 1990s, my wife Eileen and I were invited to a dinner hosted by a wealthy socialite whose political contributions had earned her a Presidential appointment and a title. At one point in the evenin...

What Can Overcome Corona?

By Isa Qasim What we see in the world these days is something the world had never seen before. This coronavirus that, like a deluge, has invaded the whole planet with no exception. Over the years, nay centuries, different parts of the world witnessed, or exercised, different kinds of hardships, wars, pains, dictatorships, agonies, disasters, etc., but never something like what we are witn...

Is AIPAC Losing Its Grip on Democrats?

BY Dr. James J. Zogby I came to Washington, more than four decades ago, to run the Palestine Human Rights Campaign. We founded the PHRC after hearing from lawyers and human rights activists in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian lands horrible stories of rights being abused on a daily basis. Because these stories weren’t known in the US, or they were ignored, we launched the PHRC to shine ...