Al Hawadeth for Arab Americans

اليوم :
  • :
  • :

Democrats Need “Two Wings” to Fly

Publish Date: 8/18/2020 9:20:28 AM



Published on August 14, 2020,  Washington Watch

Dr. James J. Zogby


There was a time when political party conventions were exercises in democracy. Being a delegate meant something because there were issues to be decided, there were meaningful votes to be taken, and there was excitement and suspense to the proceedings.

In our lifetimes, there have been convention debates over civil rights, the war in Vietnam, and Apartheid in South Africa. Sometimes, conventions became unpredictable and messy, but then, democracy can be messy and when it is, it’s also exciting.

In the past three decades, all this has changed and conventions have increasingly become more like scripted made-for-TV infomercials than the party gatherings of old. The votes are pro forma and the suspense is gone. The irony is that the more scripted the conventions become, the less interest the networks have in covering them. 

What prompts me to write this is not concern with TV ratings, rather the impact that this penchant for scripting the process is having on many of the thousands of delegates who, in most cases, have worked to get themselves elected to represent their candidate and district at the convention. They ran believing that they would have a say at the convention by becoming a delegate. And when they won their posts, they were elated and felt empowered. Because this convention will be virtual and therefore highly scripted, they are about to be disappointed and this concerns me.

During the week of August 17th, thousands of Democrats elected to serve as delegates to their party’s national convention will log on to their computers to view the proceedings. They will vote electronically on the party platform and for their candidate to challenge Donald Trump for the presidency.


About one-quarter of this year’s delegates are Bernie Sanders supporters. Most of them are progressive political activists and many are first-time participants in a national convention. This virtual event will not be the experience they expected. And while all of those with whom I’ve spoken are supportive of the precautions being taken in this era of pandemic, most remain in the dark about the convention plans and whether their participation is valued.

Months ago, when the 2020 Summer Olympics and a host of professional sporting events were cancelled, it should have been clear that we were going to have problems bringing tens of thousands of delegates, supporters, and media to an in-person convention in Milwaukee. Of course, I fully recognize the political calculations that had to be made, the problems of disappointing the host city, and need to have an event that would serve as a launching pad for the presidential election season. And I have no doubt that the convention planning team and DNC staffers were working round the clock weighing all these problems and exploring options.

Nevertheless, what was missing was a recognition that the convention wasn’t just the concern of the planning staff or the Biden campaign. It was personal for the delegates – especially first-timers who were looking forward to playing their part in this quadrennial drama.

Given this, it was troubling how little recognition there was for the expectations of prospective delegates and how little engagement there was with DNC members while deliberations were ongoing. I should be clear that I am not faulting the convention or DNC staff that delegates were left in the dark. This was a political call that should have come from the leadership of the party.    

With this in mind, the Bernie Delegates Network (BDN) conducted a national survey of Sanders delegates. We wanted their assessment of the planning process, whether they felt respected as delegates, and ideas they might have shared had they been consulted.


The responses were troubling. More than 80% of those who responded said they felt disrespected or ignored. And their comments made that clear.

Common refrains were that as delegates they “felt left out” and that the process was “lacking in transparency and input.” Some went further cautioning that this year’s “organizing, like the 2016 DNC convention, seems to minimize participation by Sanders delegates.”

Two others summed up the views of many:

“It should have been anticipated much earlier that the convention would be online and things planned with that in mind ahead of time. [There were] a lot of missed opportunities...” And there was “too little communication with stakeholders, that is delegates and DNC members. It has been a closed affair ¬– not seeking input...”

Frequently, the Sanders delegates also complained that they had no idea how this convention will allow their voices to be heard. They expressed the desire to participate but said they “don’t know how.” And a number of first-time delegates were concerned that they were unsure whether their participation was even valued by the party.

Some may want to dismiss these complaints as coming from the disgruntled losing side, but there is a risk in doing so. Young and old progressives are an important constituency. They make up a respectable share of Democratic voters and many are activists who represent communities Democrats will need to win. As Jesse Jackson famously noted at the 1988 Democratic convention, “it takes two wings to fly.”

In party-building, there can be no victors or vanquished. The role of a successful convention is to heal internal divisions and create unity of purpose among the various component groups of the party. In 2016, too little attention was paid to this critical undertaking. Bernie Sanders, personally, tried to soothe the disappointment felt by his delegation. But the message they received from the establishment was “We won, you lost.” They felt shut out of the proceedings and left the convention demoralized.


This year should have been different. There isn’t the same degree of rancor as there was four years ago and the Biden/Sanders task forces formed to create a unified approach to writing the platform, while producing a document not wholly satisfying to progressives, was still a good faith effort to bridge differences.

But by leaving grassroots delegates in the dark and by reducing their role to passive online viewers, we run the risk of producing a letdown that could leave hundreds of delegates alienated. What this may mean is that at the conclusion of the party confab, many first-time Sanders delegates (and some old-timers, as well) instead of being energized and engaged, may turn off their computers feeling deflated. Unity will not have been achieved.

As Democrats go forward into the fall campaign season, this can still be addressed. The progressive wing of the party will support Joe Biden for president, because they want to defeat Donald Trump. But it will be important to directly engage the hundreds of activists who worked hard to become delegates and who represent important constituencies Democrats will need for their “two wings” to fly.


Dr. James J. Zogby ©


Arab American Institute

Read Too

قانون البنية الأساسية البشرية (البنية التحتية)What's in the $3.5 Trillion Infrastructure Package?

English article follows يطرح الديمقراطيون مشروعا ضخما تبلغ قيمته 3.5 تريليون دولار يطلق عليه مشروع قانون البنية الأساسية البشرية. ويتوزع المبلغ المقترح على 1.8 ترليون دولار لتلبية متطلبات اللجنة المالية اضافة للتخفيضات الضريبية للأميركيين الذين يحققون أقل من 400 ألف دولار وتخفيض أسعار الأدوية الموصوفة طبيا. 726 بليون للتعليم والتدريب والصحة 332 بليون للإسكان والاراضي 265 بليون الإنفاق على...

Juneteenth (June 19) is federal holiday. (يونيو 19) أصبح عطلة اتحادية.

نسخةالصورة عن موقع الوايت هاوس النسخة العربية في الاسفل by: Adnan Khalil President Joe Biden said: “One hundred and fifty-six years ago — one hundred and fifty-six years — June 19th, 1865 — John, a major general of the Union Army arrived in Galveston, Texas, to enforce the Emancipation Proclamation and free the last enslaved Americans in Texas from bondage. A day, as you ...

مؤشرات على تنامي دور القوات المسلحة في السياسة الغربية Western Militaries Speak Out

مؤشرات على تنامي دور القوات المسلحة في السياسة الغربية Western Militaries Speak Out May 25, 2021 (English version follows) د. منذر سليمان وجعفر الجعفري تتوالى السّردية الرسميّة الأميركيّة في رسم صورة دور أفرع القوات المسلحة كافة، بعيداً من تدخلها في رسم السياسات الأميركية المتعددة أو التأثير فيها، فيما يتطور العالم، وكذلك متطلبات الاستراتيجية الأميركية الكونية. وقد شهدت أميرك...

موعظة» الصراع الفلسطيني الإسرائيلي Lessons That Must Be Learned

موعظة» الصراع الفلسطيني الإسرائيلي English version follows د. جيمس زغبي هناك دروس يتعين تعلمها من الأحداث المأساوية التي مر بها الصراع الإسرائيلي الفلسطيني لكل من له «عينان فلينظر ومن له أذنان سامعتان فليسمع». ودعنا نورد هنا بعضاً منها. فبعد التوقيع على اتفاقات سلام مع عدد من الدول العربية، شاع اعتقاد لدى كثيرين في إسرائيل ولدى أنصارهم في الغرب بأن الصراع قد انتهى. وليس الأمر...

مشروع قانون تاريخي في الكونجرس يتنصر للفلسطينيين MCCOLLUM INTRODUCES HISTORIC LEGISLATION

English Press Release follows الحوادث لعرب أمريكا- واشنطن: أصدرت عضوة الكونغرس بيتي ماكولوم (DFL-Minn.) البيان التالي اليوم بعد تقديمها للكونجرس مشروعا لقانون الدفاع عن حقوق الإنسان للأطفال والأسر الفلسطينية التي تعيش تحت الاحتلال العسكري الإسرائيلي، (التشريع رقم 115 و 116 لتعزيز حقوق الإنسان وسلامة الأطفال الفلسطينيين). يحظر تشريع ماكولوم على إسرائيل استخدام أموال دافعي الضرائب الأمريكيين في ا...

US Military Moves Against Russia and China

The last few weeks have been busy ones for the US military as they have redeployed several units to meet what US leadership perceived to be potential threats by Russia and China. American bombers have deployed to Norway for the first time. Two US nuclear super carriers are holding maneuvers in the South China Sea, the National Guard is reconfiguring to better meet Russian and Chinese military...

Democrats Need “Two Wings” to Fly

Published on August 14, 2020, Washington Watch Dr. James J. Zogby There was a time when political party conventions were exercises in democracy. Being a delegate meant something because there were issues to be decided, there were meaningful votes to be taken, and there was excitement and suspense to the proceedings. In our lifetimes, there have been convention debates over civil ri...

Trump Is Trying to Hide US and Israeli War Crimes by Attacking the International Criminal Court

photo By OSeveno - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, Trump aims to ensure that no American or Israeli is brought to the International Criminal Court for war crimes and crimes against humanity. BY Marjorie Cohn, Truthout PUBLISHED July 8, 2020 A war crimes complaint has been filed against Donald Trump, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Neta...

Special Elections Give Insight into November Election

By Mounzer A. Sleiman, Ph.D and Jafar Al-Jafari Although relatively insignificant, special elections show political experts a lot. While polls show the leanings of adults, registered voters, and likely voters, special elections show who the real voters prefer. The other difference is that special elections, although small have an impact. In Tuesday’s case, they narrowed the Democra...

The American Corona Virus Apocalypse – What to Expect and What Could Happen

23 March 2020 Part 1/2 series: The American Corona Virus Apocalypse – What to Expect and What Could Happen A month ago, predictions about the course of the Corona virus were varied. Many insisted it was merely a typical mild winter sickness that would quickly dissipate when the weather got warmer. Others warned this was a pandemic that could impact the world and how we live for decad...

وباء كورونا استنفار شامل وسط فوضى وإنكار Coronavirus Plagues America

March 15, 2020 (English version follows) وباء كورونا وأميركا: استنفار شامل وسط فوضى وإنكار تحليل لمركز الدراسات العربية والامريكية بعد طول انتظار سمته التخبط والفوضى والنكران، اضطر البيت الابيض للتعامل مع تفشي وباء "كورونا" واتخاذ بعض الإجراءات الاحترازية للوقاية منه، وذلك في اليوم التالي لإعلان "منظمة الصحة الدولية" الوباء بتصنيفه جائحة تهدد البشرية جمعاء. وتراجع عقب...

ملخص دراسات واصدارات مراكز الابحاث, PUBLICATIONS, AND ARTICLES

February 8, 2020 الانفاق العسكري الأميركي أثنت مؤسسة هاريتاج على سياسات الرئيس ترامب بزيادة مخصصات ميزانية البنتاغون "وشهدت السنوات الثلاث الأخيرة نمواً جيداً في القوات والمعدات العسكرية،" مما دفع ترامب للإعلان بأن "تم انجاز إعادة بناء قواتنا بشكل تام." وأوضحت بأن ذلك انعكس على تعزيز الجهوزية في القوات البرية بمعدل 55% ".. لكن لا يزال أمامنا مهام ينبغي إنجازها لإعادة بناء القوات الأميركية بصو...

الانسحاب من سوري تخبط في آلية صنع القرارUS decision to withdraw from Syria.

English version below التقرير الدوري لمراكز الابحاث الاميركية أشار الى تخبط في إدارة ترامب انعكس في في تعديل قرار ترامب بالانسحاب من سوريا ونورد هنا ما أصدره المركز بقلم الدكتور منذر سليمان المقدمة سوريا وانسحاب القوات الأميركية وسرعة تراجع الرئيس ترامب لمنح مزيد من الفرصة الزمنية، تحت ضغط القيادات العسكرية، أشرت على بلوغ الصدام الداخلي مرحلة متقدمة، لا سيما بعد "إقالة" وزير الدفاع واست...

عزل ترامب: حتمي أم تكهنات ورغبات Trump, Impeachment

عزل ترامب: حتمي أم تكهنات ورغبات Trump, Impeachment, and Media Hype August 25, 2018 Source: Center for American and Arab Studies/ (English version follows) عزل ترامب: حتمي أم تكهنات ورغبات تنامت في ...